Spinning Silver
Feb. 26th, 2019 08:56 amI read it Sunday night because my hold came through from the library and I downloaded it to be prepared for the power outage and then the power outage never came so I just... read it.
This is one that I think must be significantly different to read in an ebook than in hard copy, because I kept thinking surely it must nearly be over, and then I'd glance at the progress bar and it was like... 75%. The author kept introducing new POV characters, well into the book, and I feel somewhat vindicated because a beta reader for Home Out In The Wind told me they couldn't continue because it was too many different POVs and they weren't well-defined enough, and yet, here's a published novel on the nom list for Nebulas and Hugos and 45% of the way through the book we've got yet another first-person narrator whose name we don't find out for pages. (You figure out it's a new person because she begins with "my father" and mentions a character by name who we've never met as being a close person, and eventually we get that she's a whole new person we never knew about before.)
I don't want to give away any of it, of course-- it's typical Naomi Novik (if I can say that, having read only one other book under that name) in that the magic is much more practical and yet more mystical than one expects. The premise is the fairytale peasant girl who can spin silver into gold; ( if you're going to read it anyway then skip, it's best to read without any idea of what's going to happen! but if you're on the fence, click, they're not spoilers )
Anyway I have to return that library book soon, so I'm rereading but I don't think I'll write any fic. I have to get back to my own original work, which has bogged down again and I sort of know why but sort of don't, and I'm going to have to unravel another thirty thousand words, and that sucks, I've already deleted ten thousand and started over at the problem spot, but I clearly started over wrong. I'm sure I can salvage them-- it's not really like knitting, that stuff isn't really gone, it's more like sewing where you've got to seam-rip it and recut the pattern piece and put it back in, and you can probably reuse most of the fabric from the muslin for other stuff and it's no big deal, you had to do that work to get where you are and it's fine, just write it down for the love of God, mark your alterations on your pattern you idiot, and I never do, I just fix it and say I'll remember next time I cut this piece but then I don't.
This is one that I think must be significantly different to read in an ebook than in hard copy, because I kept thinking surely it must nearly be over, and then I'd glance at the progress bar and it was like... 75%. The author kept introducing new POV characters, well into the book, and I feel somewhat vindicated because a beta reader for Home Out In The Wind told me they couldn't continue because it was too many different POVs and they weren't well-defined enough, and yet, here's a published novel on the nom list for Nebulas and Hugos and 45% of the way through the book we've got yet another first-person narrator whose name we don't find out for pages. (You figure out it's a new person because she begins with "my father" and mentions a character by name who we've never met as being a close person, and eventually we get that she's a whole new person we never knew about before.)
I don't want to give away any of it, of course-- it's typical Naomi Novik (if I can say that, having read only one other book under that name) in that the magic is much more practical and yet more mystical than one expects. The premise is the fairytale peasant girl who can spin silver into gold; ( if you're going to read it anyway then skip, it's best to read without any idea of what's going to happen! but if you're on the fence, click, they're not spoilers )
Anyway I have to return that library book soon, so I'm rereading but I don't think I'll write any fic. I have to get back to my own original work, which has bogged down again and I sort of know why but sort of don't, and I'm going to have to unravel another thirty thousand words, and that sucks, I've already deleted ten thousand and started over at the problem spot, but I clearly started over wrong. I'm sure I can salvage them-- it's not really like knitting, that stuff isn't really gone, it's more like sewing where you've got to seam-rip it and recut the pattern piece and put it back in, and you can probably reuse most of the fabric from the muslin for other stuff and it's no big deal, you had to do that work to get where you are and it's fine, just write it down for the love of God, mark your alterations on your pattern you idiot, and I never do, I just fix it and say I'll remember next time I cut this piece but then I don't.