List of Iraq War Casualties, with photographs (cnn.com).
A new livejournal community started by a friend, devoted to understanding the human toll of the Iraq war, as viewed through the lists of casualties provided by the Department of Defense: Speaking the Dead.
We went to see Fahrenheit 9/11 with the visiting Norwegian cousins Andreas and Aleksander because they were interested in what my views on it would be. Both of them have served in Norway's military; I don't remember what Andreas, now 24, did, but I know Aleksander, now 22, was an M.P. and served in Germany with NATO.
The movie ended and we walked silently out of the theater, and stood in the lobby a moment. We joked briefly about something unrelated, walked out to the car, got into it, and drove home.
We then proceeded to drink four bottles of wine and talk about entirely unrelated things for the next eight hours or so.
I just couldn't bear to think about any of it anymore. None of it was a surprise to me. None of it was anything I hadn't heard before. It wasn't particularly well-made. It was just putting it all in one place and expressing the frustrations and suspicions of a lot of people-- I have many friends who have complained about these things, and I myself promised that if Bush were elected in 2000 I would leave the country. My excuse for not doing so is that he wasn't really elected. Also, it's hard to get a visa to move to Canada. (Dave got as far as the Canadian Embassy to pick up an information packet.)
So... We stayed up until 3:30 playing card games and drinking, and not talking about the movie or the war or current events at all, and then Fiona had to drive home (she'd been drinking only coffee for hours). I hugged her and cried for a few minutes before I let her go, though we had all been very cheerful up to then. I dried my tears, bade her farewell, and we all went to bed. Then I cried for another hour.
Not about anything in particular, but just... because. (Ah, I note that I wrote a post here before I went to sleep. Yes, I was a little overwrought and a little not-sober. I remember writing it now, but had sort of forgotten when I wrote this entry.)
Katy and Adam are going back to Iraq in January, both with the 3rd Infantry Division of the U.S. Army. (Currently stationed in Ft. Stewart, Georgia.)
![]()
For those who don't know, my sister Cap't Kathleen Smith is in the Ordnance branch of the Army. As she explains it, Ordnance is "bombs and trucks": in essence, her job generally entails managing the paperwork to ensure that supplies and personnel are put where they need to be. Her husband Cap't Adam Smith is an M.P. (Military Policeman), and as far as I can tell mostly drives around in Hum-Vees trying to keep people out of trouble. During their last tour of duty in Iraq (Adam was with the 1 Armored Division near Baghdad; Katy [who was then Cap't Kelly] was near the Baghdad Airport and I think was mostly doing work with personnel paperwork, including all the paperwork necessary when someone gets killed), Katy was shot at once (Adam was angry because he felt proper precautions weren't taken) and Adam came within three feet of triggering an Improvised Explosive Device. They were there from March to September of 2003, I think. But as with all of this information, there's a lot I wasn't really filled in on at the time, and my memory is hazy. I'm not sure what Katy does, and I'm not sure what Adam does, and I'm not positive where they were and what they've done. All I know is what I remember being told.
I picked them up at the airport when they came back to the States, and both of them were fine and healthy, but Adam expressed scorn when he saw a civilian H-2 on the highway ("Why would you want them? They're noisy and uncomfortable, and the only point to 'em is that they're armored, which the H-2s aren't!"), and both were exceedingly leery of driving near any debris in the road because in Iraq, road debris is almost always booby-trapped with IEDs, and Katy's done an awful lot of paperwork for those whose limbs have been blown off in IED explosions.
I just wish I could ask someone who's actually in charge of this war to assure me that this whole thing is really worth risking my sister's life.
I don't want to accuse anyone. I'm not angry. I'm too tired to be angry. But I love my sister, and my new brother-in-law though I haven't had a chance to get to know him (she loves him, anyway). I know what she is worth to me. And I want to feel that those sending her into harm's way understand what she is worth to me. Multiply that by the thousands of troops, and it's a lot of love and worry that I hope they realize this war has to be worth.
Because it has to be.
I didn't protest the war when it started because I was just too worried. There's too much to worry about. And protesting is futile, or has proven to be so far. My father served in Vietnam from 1968 to 1969, and I know how much it hurt him that he was not supported by his own people; he was a volunteer and enlisted because he felt it was his duty as a patriot and a fortunate son of America, to give back to the country. He has never recovered from the cynicism the protest movement that called him a babykiller inspired in him. The protests of that era just don't resonate with me; I see the protestors and want to smack them for directing their hostility in ineffective ways. Throwing chunks of concrete with embedded nails at frightened national guardsmen is not a good way to change the world. Those who get hurt are never those who make the decisions.
And, at that point, I didn't want to get into anything awkward with Katy. I still don't. I get to speak to her seldom enough that I have better things to talk about. Sometimes you just have to assume it's worth it, and in the end it will all be justified.
God only knows whether it will.
I sure as hell don't know, and don't know what to do about it. I'm a writer, so I write. I'm a human, so I feel. I'm a sister, so I worry.