(no subject)

via https://ift.tt/mPG8gUs

mikkeneko https://mikkeneko.tumblr.com/post/719048212712980480/so-heres-my-beef-with-chatgpt-even-aside-from :

So here’s my beef with ChatGPT. Even aside from the issues with plagiarism, cheating, people using it to fake the work that they absolutely need to be actually doing, &etc.

With the advent of the internet we’ve been in a situation where all the knowledge available to humanity could, conceivably, be made available to everyone at all times. We’ve had enormous public works built towards that purpose – libraries, Wikipedia, archives, everything. But an increasing problem as the years have gone by has been the problem of sorting out the signal from the noise. Sorting out real, helpful advice from scams and snake-oil. Paths that lead to dead-ends as sources of information go down and don’t come back up. Trying to figure out who’s a real expert, who’s even a real person in a sea of fake generated avatars. Distinguishing wheat from chaff, usable material from trash.

And the makers of ChatGPT – and every other AI programmer who’s now trying to jump on the bandwagon – is looking at this problem and saying “You know what this situation needs? More noise. More fakes. More chaff. More dead-ends and empty shells. I think we have TOO MUCH useful information and real expertise. I think we should shake things up by adding more utterly contentless garbage to the mix.” And they created an automated noise generator.

Just imagine being on the bank of a pond and saying “ah, this is a lovely pond, the fish and plants are so beautiful, I’m just having trouble seeing them through the silt in the water” and the person next to you says “I’m going to build a factory on the bank of this pond that does nothing but pour more dirt into it. All day. Every day. Nonstop.” And then everyone else overhears them and says “Oh, what a fantastic idea! I’m going to create my OWN sludge-factory to get in on this action!” (Your picture was not posted)