larkandkatydid: “Jingle-Jangle” is
Aug. 26th, 2018 04:04 pmvia https://ift.tt/2obPeJv
larkandkatydid:
“Jingle-Jangle” is actually a technical term is social science research that describes the challenge of measuring/describing/agreeing on important sociological concepts because either people are using different words to describe the same experience (jingle) and/or they are using the same words to describe very different experiences (jangle).
(it also could be the reverse. I’m not looking it up to double check)
In my work we keep getting caught in the jingle-jangle jungle around the term “empathy”. Really. I swear. I’m not just beating you over the head with the lessons of this cryptic parable. I really did have to spend 2 hours this week debating the difference between “empathy” and “listening”. Oh, you think that’s obvious but IT IS NOT!
Anyway, it’s a real term for a real thing that happens all the fucking time and if you don’t notice it happening you will find yourself arguing with people you don’t actually disagree with.
My mother, a trained museum curator volunteering in her retirement for the archives of the county historical society, is currently trapped in an utter hell of this nature: a pair of librarians are also volunteering to help organize certain manuscripts in the collection, and they come in during hours that do not overlap with those my mother spends there.
And they have extremely specific, and not identical, definitions of certain terms, like “catalogue” and “accession”. They mean DIFFERENT THINGS to curators and librarians, and my mother is not entirely sure WHAT librarians think those things mean, but they do NOT mean the same things as they mean to HER. And so week after week she leaves them notes, and she comes back to bewildered answers and things done that weren’t what she intended at all, and so on.
She sighed and said she’s going to have to make a point of coming in when they’re there, so they can just sit down and define their terms once and for all…
(Your picture was not posted)
larkandkatydid:
“Jingle-Jangle” is actually a technical term is social science research that describes the challenge of measuring/describing/agreeing on important sociological concepts because either people are using different words to describe the same experience (jingle) and/or they are using the same words to describe very different experiences (jangle).
(it also could be the reverse. I’m not looking it up to double check)
In my work we keep getting caught in the jingle-jangle jungle around the term “empathy”. Really. I swear. I’m not just beating you over the head with the lessons of this cryptic parable. I really did have to spend 2 hours this week debating the difference between “empathy” and “listening”. Oh, you think that’s obvious but IT IS NOT!
Anyway, it’s a real term for a real thing that happens all the fucking time and if you don’t notice it happening you will find yourself arguing with people you don’t actually disagree with.
My mother, a trained museum curator volunteering in her retirement for the archives of the county historical society, is currently trapped in an utter hell of this nature: a pair of librarians are also volunteering to help organize certain manuscripts in the collection, and they come in during hours that do not overlap with those my mother spends there.
And they have extremely specific, and not identical, definitions of certain terms, like “catalogue” and “accession”. They mean DIFFERENT THINGS to curators and librarians, and my mother is not entirely sure WHAT librarians think those things mean, but they do NOT mean the same things as they mean to HER. And so week after week she leaves them notes, and she comes back to bewildered answers and things done that weren’t what she intended at all, and so on.
She sighed and said she’s going to have to make a point of coming in when they’re there, so they can just sit down and define their terms once and for all…
(Your picture was not posted)